View Single Post
  #7  
Old January 22nd, 2007
solidwalnut's Avatar
solidwalnut solidwalnut is offline
Moderator | Lesson Contributor

Playing guitar for what seems like forever.
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Last Online: 2 Days Ago 04:12 PM
Location: Phoenix, AZ USA
Posts: 1,394


Quote:
Originally Posted by Lcjones
This was written tonight. After going over some posts regarding rhymes I thought I'd pony up and rhyme like the dickens! But rest assured this is a real song in progress and will eventually find it's way ...... some where.

Your deep critique is more than welcome.


It's an acoustic only practice recording. Sniffles are no charge.
Yes sir, may I have another!! Several more please! They add alot of flavor

Generally speaking, I think this song flows very nicely. I have trouble over the stuttering of syllables, the breaking up of words. They don't bother me a great deal, but they seem to stick out to me. And if they stick out, they should be worth something, imo!

I think the melody and the chording are a wonderful fit. It's a sing-songy type like you and I grew up loving and so I am probably biased. But hey, there's alot of people out there like me and you

From reading your comments I know that you already realize that you might be able to work with the tension and release. I think that's one component of this that would help to bring it together.

The other area is that I think the lyric could use some better imagery. While really good and true, it all seems a bit plain. I have trouble relating to it because I'm not feeling that you're telling me your story, just some story from somebody else, if that makes sense. You know, maybe add in that element that says that these are your feelings you're laying out here. Tell us this story, that we have heard before, in a way that makes it Les' story.

That's about it for now, my friend. A great start. I really look forward to what you might be able to do with this.



Steve


Steve Cass
Solid Walnut Music/ASCAP

Becoming a great guitarist has less to do with fancy moves than it does becoming a master of the basics and learning musicianship.
It's not what you can't do. It's how you play what you already know.

Lessons for the Beginner and Beyond
"Rhythm guitar is a trip that alot of people miss"
-- Tom Petty
Reply With Quote