I was tempted to sit on the fence but I'm swayed toward the arguments of Peptic and Coldethyl. It's a good idea Krissovo but it could be divisive, I think competition is healthy but in this case may go against the spirit of the forum, as it is intended to be used by all sorts of guitar players at many different levels, adding a competitive edge may cause friction. It might work if the awards were broken up into categories, say an award for the best Alternative, best Blues etc. but Peptic does have a point, members will always have their favourites, it could end up like the Eurovision song Contest where Russia will always vote for Ukraine and no one ever votes for the UK because we're not joined at the hip with Europe. So it again may not be the most popular opinion but this type of thing may be too divisive and alienate certain Members albeit unintentionally.
Probably the best way to get a better and fairer idea of how members feel would be to do a poll and let the Democratic process decide, at the moment this thread is a bit one sided, I'm sure a lot of members would agree with the idea.
You don't stop laughing when you grow old; you grow old when you stop laughing.