Quote:
|
Originally Posted by nocat
I too used Bob's song to try and jam with... And even though his response was positive
and complementary, I got the distinct impression that doing so was not cool... Not from
Bob, he seemed to be ok with it, but by the way it was ignored... And rightly so...!!!
I came to the realisation that some stuff was not to be tinkered with and the results
posted for public audience. I should have kept it to my self. I felt bad about it and
promptly killed the link... Therefore, the public apology and the "lesson learned" comment. 
I have since listened to several versions of Hallelujah, And I must say, with all honesty
that they all pale in comparison with Bob's. Even Leonard Cohen sounds dull and lifeless in contrast...!!! |
I think it is more your take got lost in the shuffle. It is a good idea to start a new thread when you upload a take. I missed your take and now the link is dead. As long as you have the authers permission to tinker with his tune than thats cool. It is better to just get the backtrack and put your own melody over it. Adding to a finished tune is like adding to a finished painting. It can be done but, you have to be very very good to pull it off.